Asrar Ahmad Kichloo AIR-287, CSE-21 Medical Science
Asrar Ahmad Kichloo cleared UPSC CSE-21 with AIR-287. This was his 5th attempt and 2nd selection.
DDecode Civils
· 6 min read
Asrar Ahmad Kichloo cleared UPSC CSE-21 with AIR-287. This was his 5th attempt and 2nd selection. In his first 2 attempts, he could not clear prelims while in latest 3 attempts he cleared even Forest cut-off and also got selected twice!
Introduction
Brief intro about myself. I am Asrar Ahmad Kichloo. I come from Jammu & Kashmir. I am a medical graduate & I completed my MBBS in 2016 from GMCH Jammu. I have cleared UPSC CSE twice with AIR 248 in CSE 2019 & AIR 287 in CSE 2021 with Medical Science as my optional subject & I am currently in IRS (C&IT).
This was my 5th attempt. I gave my first attempt in 2017. I struggled with prelims initially & couldn’t clear it in 2017 & 2018. Then I changed my strategy & was able to clear prelims thrice (scoring above IFoS cutoff in all 3 prelims). I have given 3 mains, 3 interviews & have got selected twice. My scores in Medical science were 252 (2019), 274 (2020) & 267 (2021).
Medical Science (Optional Subject)
Booklist for Medical Science Optional Subject-
1) Study from the books that you have already covered during your graduation. No need to buy new books. I am sharing the sources that I had referred to.
2) Paper 1 Sources-
Anatomy- BD Chaurasia + Dr Parikshit Zade’s notes.
Embryology by Inderbir Singh
Physiology- Guyton & Hall + Dr Parikshit Zade’s notes
Biochemistry- Satyanarayana + Dr Parikshit Zade’s notes
I am trying to be as honest as I can. My intention is just to guide fellow medicos who intend to sit for UPSC CSE exam. After giving 3 mains with Medical Science subject, I felt the need to share my thoughts & experiences(& experiences of many of my colleagues) as very little info is available online regarding this subject.
1) Is Medical Science a good optional subject?
My answer would be- It is not a very good optional subject. You can click on this link & watch the video by Dr. Suyash Chavan to know why.
It may be a decent optional for those MBBS graduates who decide to prepare the exam during their graduation especially during 2nd prof. They can keep the mains syllabus in mind & prepare the notes accordingly right from the college days. They don’t need to do any extra work. Just need to focus little more on topics mentioned in the syllabus.
For those who decide to go for CSE during internship or after MBBS or even after their PG- Taking a smaller optional subject with some overlap with GS might be a wiser decision as it may save time, may be equally scoring (if not more) & may help in in GS too.
Scoring pattern is very uncertain in Med Sci. Since last 3 years(CSE 2019, 2020 & 2021) no-one has managed to score 300+ in this subject.
We get a feeling that since we have studied this subject during your graduation, we can write something in our answers even if we aren’t able to revise it well. But in that case, we will score only something in this subject.
2) Is it lengthy?
Very lengthy. Don’t take the syllabus at face value. The topics mentioned in it seem easy but when you have to cover all of the topics together (both papers are held on the same day), it becomes hell of a task.
I gave 3 mains with this optional scoring 252, 274 & 267. I had to compromise my GS (managed to score 400+ both times when I got recommended, but needed more to get a double digit rank) as this optional subject took 65-75% of my time between prelims & mains. It is better to take a smaller optional & try to score 430+ in GS. You either need 430+ in GS or 280+ in optional subject to get a rank in top 70.
3) Now, what are the advantages of taking this optional?
You would have covered most of the topics during your graduation.
You don’t need to search for new books.
Coaching is not required.
Paper 1 doesn’t need a dedicated test series as topics are mostly factual (paper 2 needs practice as mostly clinical cases are given).
4) So, should I take Med Science as my optional subject?
I would recommend not to take it unless you are very confident about it & preferably if you decide to prepare for CSE during MBBS days.
5) Who should take Med Sci as his/her optional?
Only MBBS graduates. BDS, BAMS etc should not take it as a major portion of the syllabus isn’t covered during their graduation & even MBBS graduates find it too difficult to manage.
6) Alternatives for MBBS candidates? If I could go back, I would take Anthropology or PSIR.
7) How to attempt Med science optional paper?
I followed Dr Anand Kr Sharma’s strategy of writing Med Science answers during my CSE 2020 & 2021 attempts which helped me a lot. Sharing the links here-
Paper 1 - https://youtu.be/dOYl2entv5E
Paper 2 - https://youtu.be/PMCCIQMoSZk
Briefly-
Paper 1-
Make lots of coloured diagrams. Try to explain with diagrams eg draw blood stains/wounds in forensic medicine.
Use flowcharts as much as possible eg Physiology, Biochem(eg Protein synthesis).
Make tables as much as possible eg in Biochemistry- for types of Jaundice & investigations required for them.
Write clinical aspects in 1-2 lines in the end.
Stratify- eg Lab diagnosis in micro- Samples required, transport medium, Direct microscopy, culture, biochemistry, Other tests like serology, PCR etc.
Write DDx even if not asked(try to cover DDX of common ailments like headache, breathlessness, chest pain, abdominal pain, hematuria etc)
Treatment- Again diversify-General measures, Specific(Non surgical including non pharma & pharmacological; surgical including pre op, op & post op), Treatment of complications.
Mention about followup in the end. In case of Pediatrics, mention about advice to be given to the parents in the end. In Obs- mention about contraception advice.
Cover short but important subjects first eg Biochemistry, Microbiology, Derma, Psychiatry & Pediatrics.
8) Few important tips for Med Sci-
I had gone through Med Science previous years question papers & accordingly tried to find the most important areas from where questions are asked again & again and which need to be covered first of all eg PCR in Biochem, Facial Nerve in Anatomy etc
Also I found out from the PYQ papers that there are some topics which aren’t mentioned in the syllabus but from where questions have been asked repeatedly. Eg Bronchopulmonary segments- 3 times UPSC has asked question on this topic although it isn’t mentioned in the syllabus.
2 comments
Discussion
Aishwarya
Sir kindly post history optional strategies. Thankyou
Aishwarya
Sir kindly post history optional strategies.